I wonder if evangelicals are getting it right, I mean, about evangelism. Several things I have read recently sadden me and make me wonder what we are doing wrong. Perhaps I am succumbing to the Autumn blues that strike me the time of year. I dunno. But I am worried.
According to the Barna group (www.barna.org) in 2009-2010
28% of the adult population, roughly 65 million people, did not attend
any church function in the last 6 months. Although this number is down from its high point in the last quarter century of 32% it seems like we should be making more progress. More disturbing is that it seems that many of these “un-churched” folks are self-proclaimed Christians. 61% of the un-churched say they are Christians. 37% say they avoid church because they have been hurt deeply by Christians or the church in the past.
Traditionally women seem to man the pews in greater numbers than men, something evangelicals have lamented over for years. And men do lead in the number of un-churched people in America. But women lead in the number of un-churched people who say they are Christians. Protestants outnumber Catholics. It might be time to ask ourselves, what is going on?
A great deal of effort has been spent by Churches to make services more “relevant” sermons more practical, the music more hip. I’m not saying that doing so is a bad thing. I firmly believe that each generation needs to recast eternal truth in modern day expressions. And it just might be, basedon the numbers, that it has helped. The numbers of un-churched are down. Or so it would seem.
Other research shows that the number of people “outside” the church grows with each new generation. Young people are becoming less and less churched. Only 40% of people in the 16-29 age group are outside the church compared to 27% in the 42-50 age group.
When young people were asked to identify their impressions of Christianity, one of the common themes was “Christianity is changed from what it used to be” and “Christianity in today’s society no longer looks like Jesus.” These comments were the most frequent unprompted images that young people called to mind, mentioned by one-quarter of both young non-Christians (23%) and born again Christians (22%). This is where the term “un-Christian” came from – both those inside the church and outside of it who said that something was broken in the present-day expression of Christianity.
So what’s wrong? What is broken? Aren’t the hip services working?
I know from my experience that is not Biblical teaching that will bring people back to church. They have to come back to God first. The Great Commission to take the gospel to the world has become the Great Omission. We are falling down on the task.
Some other data may help us find our way.
1. We aren’t reaching men. Women typically outnumber men in church (53%), bible studies (60%), Sunday school (59%), and volunteer work (57%). But men out number women in home churches (56%).
2. We aren’t reaching singles. 69% of church volunteers are married. Non married church attenders are the least reached, 1/5 of church attenders and volunteers are single.
3. We aren’t reaching the youth. Churches are filled with old people, most of them over the age of 45. 56% of the spiritually active in a church are 45+. Nationally, 52% of the population is 45+.
Other data provides hope.
Small groups encourage personal bible reading and study. Two-thirds of church attenders (67%) said they had read the Bible outside of church in the last week – whether their church was a conventional or house church. Small group attenders were more likely to read the Bible personally (84%) higher even than Sunday school attenders and volunteers (77%).
Maybe instead of making our churches more attractive we need to make a change altogether. Maybe our churches should be a spring board for neighborhood (and even global) ministries done by, suprise!, the people and not the clergy or paid staff. Maybe we are just training stations and an encouragement stop for those busy in the community.
You might be thinking to yourself, Isn’t that what bible believing, evangelical, solid Christian churches are already doing? We aren’t failing in our mission, people are just more secular and sinful. I don’t disagree that it”s not a new idea I am proposing. But so often in church we are kept way too busy to connect with our neighbors and friends.
Although there will be millions of people who abandon the entire faith community for the usual reasons -hurtful experiences in churches, lack of interest in spiritual matters, prioritizing other dimensions of their life – a growing percentage of church dropouts will be those who leave a local church in order to intentionally increase their focus on faith and to relate to God through different means. I don’t think that is a bad thing.